Best for
- A2–B1 learners outgrowing beginner drills
- Learners who can study but cannot follow natural language
- People deciding whether to keep or replace a first app
Watch for
- An ‘intermediate’ label can hide uneven skills
- More difficulty is not useful when comprehension collapses
- A new app cannot fix an undefined plateau
Documented shortlist
Affiliate availability and commission are not ranking inputs. The selected LingQ destination on this page is a disclosed affiliate link; other destinations are ordinary merchant links. Read the disclosure.
LingQ
DocumentedA self-directed reading and listening environment built around authentic content, saved words and imported material.
Best fit: Learners who want large amounts of reading and listening input
Watch: The open library is not a mandatory linear course
LingoPie
DocumentedA video-first platform using shows, films and short-form media with interactive subtitles and playback tools.
Best fit: Visual learners who stay engaged with series and films
Watch: It is not a conventional linear CEFR course
Busuu
DocumentedA structured course platform with short lessons, study plans and corrections from a learner community.
Best fit: Learners who want a CEFR-oriented course sequence
Watch: Language coverage and level ceilings differ
Pimsleur
DocumentedAn audio-first programme centred on recall, speaking and listening in roughly 30-minute lessons.
Best fit: Audio learners and commuters
Watch: Reading and writing are secondary to audio
italki
DocumentedA marketplace for one-to-one lessons with independent professional teachers and community tutors.
Best fit: Personalised conversation and feedback
Watch: Choosing a tutor requires comparison work
Preply
DocumentedA one-to-one tutor marketplace built around a paid trial lesson and recurring 28-day lesson subscriptions.
Best fit: Learners who want a regular one-to-one teacher
Watch: Unused unscheduled lesson balance can be affected at renewal
Duolingo
DocumentedA bite-sized, gamified course system covering reading, writing, listening and speaking with a broad free core.
Best fit: Beginners building a low-friction daily course habit
Watch: Course depth and feature availability vary by language
Side-by-side evidence
Facts below were checked against vendor sources on Sep 3, 2026. Regional offers may change.
| Criterion | LingQ | LingoPie | Busuu | Pimsleur | italki | Preply | Duolingo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Learning format | reading, listening, vocabulary, structure | video, listening, vocabulary, reading | structure, speaking, listening, vocabulary | listening, speaking, structure | tutoring, speaking, structure, listening | tutoring, speaking, structure, listening | structure, reading, listening, speaking, vocabulary |
| Languages | More than 50 languages; the verified selector contained 52 | 17 published target languages; catalogue availability can vary by interface language and region | 14 languages; the published course ceiling ranges from A2 to C1 | 51 languages; the number of levels varies by language | 150+ languages are advertised across the tutor marketplace | The current public catalogue exposed 40 named language categories | 40+ languages; depth and source-language availability differ by course |
| Level context | All levels are marketed; the open content model is often easiest after the earliest beginner stage | Personalised level selection, without a published universal CEFR pathway | Strongest where the chosen language has a complete A1–C1 path | Beginner through intermediate in the deepest courses; no universal CEFR equivalence is published | Potentially A1–C2, depending on the selected tutor and lesson goal | Beginner through advanced, depending on tutor specialism | Beginner onward; nine major languages have published B2-aligned content for most learners, which is content scope rather than a guaranteed outcome |
| Access model | Permanent free tier | Time-limited trial | Permanent free tier | Time-limited trial | Paid access | Paid access | Permanent free tier |
| Free access / trial | Free account with audio and transcripts, up to 20 saved terms, five imported lessons and one playlist | Seven-day direct-purchase trial; mobile stores and previews follow different rules | Basic course access, community feedback and basic progress tracking | Seven-day trial for eligible subscriptions, converting to paid access unless cancelled | Community features are free; live lessons are paid and trial lessons are discounted, not free | No free live plan; the 25- or 50-minute trial lesson is paid | Core language courses remain available free; the US App Store advertises a 14-day Super trial |
| Pricing context | Geo-localized checkout showed CHF 13.50 monthly, CHF 107 annually or CHF 189.90 for 24 months; locale and channel can change the amount | The main checkout is dynamic; one official variant showed $83.88 annually or $229 lifetime, so the live regional offer must be rechecked | Current numeric pricing was not reliably exposed in public vendor HTML; verify at checkout | All Access was listed at $20.95 per month after the free week | Tutors set their own rates; there is no universal subscription price | Tutor-set and localized pricing; each tutor has a separate minimum four-lesson subscription cycle | No stable universal paid price; Super and Max vary by account, region, channel and promotion |
| Billing / renewal context | Recurring prepaid plans; first-time Premium purchases have a published 30-day refund window, while later charges are generally non-refundable | The seven-day trial auto-renews; current-month and post-trial annual charges are described as non-refundable | One- to 12-month terms are paid upfront and auto-renew; the first Premium payment has a published 14-day guarantee, excluding renewals | Single-language, All Access and lifetime options vary; direct subscription availability is limited by country and store terms can differ | Availability, price, schedule and lesson structure depend on the tutor | Tutor-specific subscriptions renew every 28 days; cancel at least 24 hours before billing and review current lesson-expiry rules | Paid plans auto-renew through the purchase channel; no universal public refund guarantee was verified |
| Platforms | Web, iOS and Android; offline access is a Premium feature | Web, iOS, Android and selected TV platforms; iOS supports limited offline downloads | Web, iOS and Android; offline access requires Premium | Web, iOS and Android with hands-free and offline app use | Web, iOS and Android with video-classroom options | Web and mobile apps | Web, iOS and Android; Max feature and language availability varies |
Diagnose the plateau before choosing the app
A learner may recognise lesson content but miss natural speech, understand input but fail to respond, read comfortably but avoid writing, or have one unresolved grammar system. Those are different transition problems.
Choose one observable failure from recent study. The next product must change that task, not simply refresh the interface.
- Input gap: the main message disappears at natural speed.
- Activation gap: known language is slow to retrieve.
- Structure gap: recurring forms still block meaning or production.
- Feedback gap: errors repeat without useful correction.
For authentic input volume
LingQ supports reading and listening around chosen or imported content. LingoPie uses video, visual context and interactive subtitles. Both can move beyond controlled dialogues, but they ask the learner to judge difficulty.
Start with material whose main situation remains understandable. Reduce lookup, subtitle dependence or replay gradually rather than jumping directly to unsupported native content.
For speaking activation and feedback
Pimsleur provides guided spoken recall; a tutor provides unpredictable turns and responsive correction. Choose recall when the problem is producing familiar language on cue. Choose tutoring when negotiation, register or specialised goals matter.
Schedule output around topics already met in input. A conversation subscription without preparation can become repeated small talk rather than deliberate progress.
When to keep a structured course
Busuu or another structured route can still be useful when the exact language extends beyond the current level and the missing material is genuinely sequential. Duolingo's published B2-aligned content in several major languages expands its possible role, but content alignment is not proof of a learner outcome.
Leave beginner review when correct answers rely on recognition, the examples no longer stretch comprehension or the same time would better serve extended input and output.
A six-week decision block
Assign one primary bottleneck, one core tool and one weekly observable task. Use the Language Environment Planner to preserve complementary skills without turning the schedule into a stack of subscriptions.
At the checkpoint, compare task performance, support required, completed sessions and total cost. Continue, combine or switch based on that evidence.
Decision criteria
Primary sources
Material claims link to primary or authoritative sources. A link is not an endorsement.
- LingQ: Official pricing
- LingQ: How LingQ works
- LingQ: Subscription terms
- LingoPie: Supported languages
- LingoPie: Trial terms
- LingoPie: Official pricing
- Busuu: Languages and levels
- Busuu: Free and Premium
- Busuu: Premium plans
- Pimsleur: Languages
- Pimsleur: Plans and trial
- Pimsleur: Official offer
- italki: Official iOS listing
- italki: Official Android listing
- Preply: Official Spanish tutor listings
- Preply: Trial lesson policy
- Preply: Subscription model
- Duolingo: Official course catalogue
- Duolingo: Published B2 content update
- Duolingo: Official US App Store listing
- Duolingo: Duolingo Max availability